To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study | By Frank Schuetzendorf

We recently participated in a bid for a restaurant space in one of Paris’ heritage train stations. After conducting a thorough feasibility study, which included researching the station, competitive set, and customer traffic flowing through the train station (we had identified 4 customer target segments: commuters, tourists, neighborhood locals, and business travelers), we knew that if we won the bid and managed to execute our vision of the space, we would add significant value to the train station and that the space would have the potential to become a genuine F&B destination.

Restaurant Concept & Preparation

Our team (architect, branding and operations) got to work and presented our concept, the story and the 360° experiential model of the 7500 sqf 3-storied site to the retail committee. The concept featured:

• A brasserie concept on the ground floor for speedy, on the go dining as you would expect in train stations or airports (target market: transit passengers)
• A more traditional dining option space and VIP lounge, nestled in front of an integrated micro brewery for local craft beer production (for business breakfast and lunch or for those with more time – target market: businesspeople and tourists)
• An outfitted kitchen on the mezzanine space catering to the 1^st Floor and Ground Floor F&B dining options
• A catering venue on the first floor featuring a trendy lifestyle bar concept and a roof top with outdoor seating (target market: the locals)

* See design layout and renderings below

We were thrilled when we learned that we had won the contest and were selected by the committee. What had set us apart was the uniqueness of the concept, that we had captured the potential of the space and responded to the expectation in adding significant value to the train station, i.e. by contributing to creating a new lifestyle destination hub for shopping & dining (as a reference for a successful case study, St. Pancras Station in London had been the pioneer in creating such new lifestyle spaces in train stations).

So far, so good!

Restaurant Feasibility & Execution Phase

The following months became more grueling, once we moved from concept phase to the technical feasibility and execution phase. The further we advanced, the more we ran into roadblocks. This eventually led us to listen our experts’ opinions, which at times can be overcautious and avoid any type of risk. Legal (contract), technical execution (project feasibility) and accounting (business economics) issues were sifted through. After the red flags kept piling up, we came to terms with the reality of the project:

Legal & Contractual Implications

Train stations and airports are busy places with a lot of variables that you cannot control. Technical equipment such as water supply and evacuation, HVAC systems (heating, ventilation, air conditioning) and electrical power circuits are shared (heavy overhead contributions in maintenance, equipment not always in optimal condition, unpredictable shutdowns or maintenance works which can impact operations etc.).

Further, constraints linked to public venues such as airports and train stations creates a risk where lease holders bear the cost for any loss of activity (in our case 100% of the burden was to be absorbed by our operation), e.g. workers strike, train cancellation due to bad weather and/or operational issues, abandoned luggage requiring security protocols and hence cutting off access to our restaurant, just to name but a few.

Restaurant Technical Feasibility

The heritage train station being a protected building site (the station opened in 1850), required us to work around technical boundaries such as

1. Electrical circuits, water supply and evacuation and power supply challenges (construction works requiring the touching of floors, walls and ceiling or any space alteration, such as space redistribution or the simple drilling of holes and creating conduits to accommodate any operational needs are not permitted due to the listed heritage building class of the site)
2. The flooring slab limit, requiring a weight distribution solution to accommodate the craft brewery, which conflicted with trying to optimize the space and energy efficiency for the brewery equipment
3. The requirement of an additional elevator and its customer access for the disabled resulting in a loss of 400 sf of operational space

Business (Re)Model

The many issues that came to light required us, as operators, to run the numbers and revisit the financial feasibility again. We soon realized that the hurdles encountered in trying to bring the project to life, would have resulted in major project cost increases and a high level of uncertainty, which in result made the project unviable in its state for any private profit-oriented company to proceed.

NB: We usually identify such issues before recommending our customers to engage in a lease, but as this exceptional venue required a public bidding process, we decided, for timing and cost management purposes, not to engage in such feasibility study before being sure we won the bid (in our case the agreement with the landlord made the project feasibility a condition for signing the lease).

We eventually pulled the plug and cut our losses, and up until to today the venue has not been leased out.

Learning when to Walk Away from a Restaurant Project

At times, even with a grand idea and project, you just must be able let things go. Far too many projects end up being poorly planned and technical and/or legal implications underestimated. What can also occur is that the initial vision of the concept becomes a big compromise, altering its authenticity and experience, leading to incomplete projects that fit into a set budget but leaving the concept half executed, killing the experience.

As F&B concept developers, we were invested and driving this project. We became emotionally attached to it, which for us is key in bringing a “baby” to life. The hospitality industry is all about people, and it’s with and through people that we create emotions. Your customers can feel the difference in experience and within spaces that have had a lot of heart during their conception.

Yet beware!

Restaurant Feasibility Takeaways

• You need to keep your ego in check. Coming to terms with reality for (privately) funded ventures in restaurant operations is an important aspect in concept design and execution. Reminder: All emotions put aside, we are running a business, and we need to make a profit, otherwise the adventure will be short lived.
• When you see the issues arising which impact project realization and exceeding budgets, you might run out of gas, or your ROI gets prolonged (shoot for a 4–5-year ROI today rather than 7 years in the past!).
• In a world where you can’t really count on customer loyalty anymore and in which restaurants need to reinvent themselves, by reinvesting, to continue offering new experiences to their customers, we need distinguish between good business sense from business non-sense.

Restaurant Concept, Layout & Renderings

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Street Level Floor Plan

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Mezzanine Kitchen Layout

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study 1st Floor Floorplan and Rooftop

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Ground Floor Rendering (Brasserie and Grab & Go)

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Brasserie and Brewery Backdrop

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Catering Area

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Lifestyle Bar

To Pursue, or NOT to Pursue Bringing an F&B Concept To life: A Restaurant Feasibility Case Study Rooftop